Hidden Talents on youtube

9 Replies 4797 Views 0 Likes 5 Participants Last post by Springie 24 Aug 2016 20:27
KT1972
KT1972 Gatchamaniac posted 19 Aug 2016 16:03
Quote Report
Ok, so about a week ago, I got a PM over at FFN, from someone who was seeking permission to read Hidden Talents on their channel. I spent a long time searching for their previous work, without much joy, before replying that I would like to see/ hear what they had done previously before I gave any consent. I got a response today, with a link, and upon searching, I discovered that my fic had already been recorded and posted! Hidden Talents recording Can't say I like it much, and had I heard his previous work earlier, I would likely have refused, but what do you guys think?
ChrisW
ChrisW Gatchamaniac posted 19 Aug 2016 17:50
Quote Report
I tried listening long enough to get to the reading but OMG he's annoying. I would have said no, too. Anyway, it's a dick move to record and post without even waiting for permission. You could ask him to take it down, privately, and if he doesn't you could ask him again publicly in the comments of the post. After that you could I suppose report him to YouTube as a violation?
ElectricWhite
ElectricWhite Gatchamaniac posted 19 Aug 2016 18:42
Quote Report
Personally, I wouldn't ask him in the comments of the post, if I even asked him at all. I'm looking it it this way: if a stranger broke into your home and robbed you, would you ask him to return your stuff, or would you call the police? By using your work without permission, that person's stolen from you. (He might try to say "Fair Use", but too much of your work has been used. Fair Use only applies to using a few quotes, not the entire work.)
Springie
Springie Her Royal Fluffiness...Swan of Swans... posted 20 Aug 2016 07:23 (edited 20 Aug 2016 07:41)
Quote Report
OMG- I agree with Chris. Unbelievably annoying. Why did he even bother to ask you if he had already recorded and posted it? I think I would ask him to take it down privately first, then publicly along with reporting him.*sigh* I know you must be frustrated. On a lighter note- it was a compliment that he chose your fic to read. It's a really nice fic! *grin*
Becky Rock
Becky Rock Gatchamaniac posted 20 Aug 2016 07:29 (edited 20 Aug 2016 07:31)
Quote Report
I've had the problem of the e versions of my three books showing up on free sites. Don't know how they managed to pirate them, but thus far my requests to them to take them off their site have failed. Sadly, as a self-publisher, the mediums I've used to pubish, iUniverse for one and Create Space with Amazon for the other two, have been no help. My latest requests included a threat to take legal proceedings but trying to find out who really owns these sites is a daunting task. At least you know who this character is. Do complain to YouTube and if that doesn't work, tell the guy you're consulting with an e-copy right lawyer and give him a deadline to remove it. Hopefully he isn't interested in bringing real trouble down on himself. Sadly, I think that is the way of things now when we put anything on the internet.
KT1972
KT1972 Gatchamaniac posted 23 Aug 2016 17:38
Quote Report
OK, guys, I PM'd him a request to take the video down, and so far he hasn't. (he's had two whole days, which is far longer than the notice he gave me before posting it!) I can't go into the public comments section, because that would mean revealing my identity to him, so instead I flagged the video to YouTube, although whether they'll get the connection or not, I don't know. I will just have to wait and see what happens next, and take it from there.
ElectricWhite
ElectricWhite Gatchamaniac posted 23 Aug 2016 17:46
Quote Report
I'm keeping my fingers crossed for you, KT.
KT1972
KT1972 Gatchamaniac posted 24 Aug 2016 15:29
Quote Report
FYI, the video has now been taken down. Thanks everyone for your support and advice, I really appreciated it. I do agree with Springie, that it was flattering that he chose one of my fics, and had it been a decent recording, then I might have let it pass, (he was complimentary of the fic at the end after all) and maybe I would even have allowed him to record other works of mine, but as it was, it was almost insulting. JSYK his FFN username is Alchemy Student, and his YouTube username is Martialartfruituser, so you'll know, if he tries to contact you, to refuse immediately and do a search on YouTube.
ElectricWhite
ElectricWhite Gatchamaniac posted 24 Aug 2016 17:00
Quote Report
Thanks for the heads up. I'm just sorry you went through this ordeal.
Springie
Springie Her Royal Fluffiness...Swan of Swans... posted 24 Aug 2016 20:27
Quote Report
Glad it has been taken down! Thanks for giving everyone a "heads up", too!
Please login to post replies.