8 Replies
61 Views
0 Likes
7 Participants
Last post by Daniella T 18 Dec 2011 07:53
Transmute Jun
Queen of the Bird Missiles
posted 17 Dec 2011 10:48
This is a really interesting look at Anderson's POV (which we see so rarely) and how he views this disaster. For BOTP, this has to be one of the worst 'defeats' the Federation has suffered, and I like the way the author has tried to get at the heart of the matter while filling in the gaps and creating a realistic scenario.
clouddancer
Gatchamaniac
posted 17 Dec 2011 14:00
I really enjoyed reading this episode from Anderson's point of view. The author did a good job rewriting this episode.
I enjoy the greater realism here (ie. Zoltar shooting the bodyguards) and Anderson's running analysis, in his thoughts, of all that's going on -makes the episode fuller and more serious than the original, written from his perspective like this (something I'm realizing that we don't get enough of, really -Anderson's perspective in fics)
Nice! We never hear from Anderson! This is such a melancholy ep- great rewrite!
gatchamarie
Gatchamaniac
posted 18 Dec 2011 01:52
Even if I'm not so familiar with many BotP episodes I must say that this is really a brilliant rewrite! I agree that in both BotP and Gatch universes, Anderson's/Nambu's POVs are rarely seen, so very much appreciated when they appear, giving the character a much more human aspect! The author did such a great job ... both with his/her writing skills and with the twist to crude realism, which we seldomly see in BotP! Thumbs up!
Daniella T
GatchaFreak
posted 18 Dec 2011 07:53
Thank you thank you thank you to my Secret Santa! This was a great surprise!!!!! Loved it all the way, and thank you to Amethyst for organising it!
DT
Please login to post replies.