Gift Exchange -- What I Wish for Christmas

9 Replies 96 Views 0 Likes 9 Participants Last post by amethyst 5 Jan 2011 09:59
amethyst
amethyst Wanted: $1000 Reward posted 19 Dec 2010 13:40
Quote Report
[unrecoverable text]
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 19 Dec 2010 13:51
Quote Report
The author has really worked hard to get inside RI's head, catching him in a rare moment of sentimentality and regret. In canon, you have to wonder if he truly is regretful of his actions, rather than merely accepting. This fic clearly comes down on the side of regretful, and of all of the consequences that accompany such emotion.
Madilayn
Madilayn Mistress of Ebil posted 19 Dec 2010 14:36
Quote Report
I really liked this. We see RI being his usual narky self - even when alone - and then also see inside to his heart and loss. The author has done a great job on this, making us look at RI in a different light.
lborgia88
lborgia88 Gatchamaniac posted 19 Dec 2010 15:23
Quote Report
Very moving and poignant, and sad, imagining Red Impulse alone at Christmas with only photographs of Ken and his own thoughts of what he wished he could do and say, and his insecurites too, wondering how he would be as a father if he really had the chance. I wish there had been more insights into his thoughts and feelings, like this, in the series itself!
Pufles65
Pufles65 Master Boardie posted 19 Dec 2010 16:30
Quote Report
I agree with Iborgia that it would have been nice to see more in depth feeling for RI in the series. This story defintely grabs at your gut and makes you just want to reach out to him and give him a hug. Amazing story! Smile
Springie
Springie Her Royal Fluffiness...Swan of Swans... posted 19 Dec 2010 18:32
Quote Report
Heart wrenching- even with RI's tough exterior you've shown his softer side and his many regrets. It's a shame that he never just decided to reveal himself to Ken once Ken was older and could defend himself.
gatchamarie
gatchamarie Gatchamaniac posted 20 Dec 2010 01:12
Quote Report
It's good to see such a character being also given a gift for Christmas ... that of revealing his softer side, even if his other side might still predominate! I agree ... I would also have wished to see a deeper examination of RI's self in the series.
UnpublishedWriter
UnpublishedWriter Gatchamaniac posted 20 Dec 2010 15:24
Quote Report
Thank you, whoever wrote this!!!!!!! Red Impulse so rarely gets sympathetic treatment that it's great to see it when it happens.
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 29 Dec 2010 18:21
Quote Report
Oooo, another story that gets inside RI's head. I find it interesting that even in his thoughts he is snide and sarcastic. and yet when he really looks into his heart he feels remorse and love for the one(s) he truly loves - and perhaps failed.
amethyst
amethyst Wanted: $1000 Reward posted 5 Jan 2011 09:59
Quote Report
UW Prompt: Fanfic, essay, or fanart (not disgusting), on either Gatch or BotP. Essay can be on any theme. Fanfic/Fanart: Would prefer one about/concerning lesser-used characters, such as Nambu/Anderson, RI/Cronus, or one of the team who doesn't get a lot of 'screen time', or much time outside the G1/G2 orbit. Gift: What I Wish for Christmas by Gatchmarie
Please login to post replies.