"Dedicated" Fics and Feedback

29 Replies 16719 Views 0 Likes 6 Participants Last post by clouddancer 27 Apr 2008 18:54
Rory
Rory Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 15:09
Quote Report
I hope no one would be offended by this little thread. Okay...I'm pretty sure at one time or another you have written a fic which you have dedicated to someone. It could be a friend. It could be a total stranger whose fics or fanarts have inspired you. I must admit that I usually post my fics in a yaoi fanfic/fanart site called "Y! Gallery", and the people there are just so nice. Dedicated fics and fanarts are graciously accepted by the recipients. But it wasn't the case when I posted my first Gatch fic. I have to be honest enough to say that I felt pretty let down that my gift fic was unappreciated. Now, I would like to know how would you feel if the person you dedicated the story to did not send you a reply or feedback?
Springie
Springie Her Royal Fluffiness...Swan of Swans... posted 27 Apr 2008 15:13
Quote Report
Oh that's just awful, Rory...I can imagine you would feel terrible...do you know for sure that the person you've dedicated the fic to has seen it? Are they a yaoi/slash fan, too?
Rory
Rory Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 15:32
Quote Report
Originally posted by Springie Oh that's just awful, Rory...I can imagine you would feel terrible...do you know for sure that the person you've dedicated the fic to has seen it? Are they a yaoi/slash fan, too?
Actually, I emailed them about it. Yes, they are yaoi/slash fic writers and fanartists. Oh well. I'm just assuming that the story is not the kind they like. But...well...it's still rather disappointing. I'm glad some people liked it in Y! Gallery though. But still...
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 15:35
Quote Report
Originally posted by Rory
Originally posted by Springie Oh that's just awful, Rory...I can imagine you would feel terrible...do you know for sure that the person you've dedicated the fic to has seen it? Are they a yaoi/slash fan, too?
Actually, I emailed them about it. Yes, they are yaoi/slash fic writers and fanartists. Oh well. I'm just assuming that the story is not the kind they like. But...well...it's still rather disappointing. I'm glad some people liked it in Y! Gallery though. But still...
Don't worry about it, Rory. Post here and you'll get all the love you can stand. kneelsuckers
Ebonyswanne
Ebonyswanne Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 15:40
Quote Report
Rory do you know the person well??? Or you just like their work. If its just been posted they may not have had time to read it yet!
Rory
Rory Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 15:56
Quote Report
Originally posted by Ebonyswanne Rory do you know the person well??? Or you just like their work. If its just been posted they may not have had time to read it yet!
No, but she responds to people who write to her. I actually emailed her but she never replied. I posted it April 9, so it's been quite a long time.
Rory
Rory Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 15:59
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight Don't worry about it, Rory. Post here and you'll get all the love you can stand. kneelsuckers
I still have my apprehensions because it is a slash story. I'll see if I can post it tomorrow. I have an interview to do for a breast cancer article today. And, no, it's not really that I need love. Maybe just a simple acknowledgement, like a "Thank you" would do.
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 16:04
Quote Report
Rory, perhaps if the person does not know you, has not spoken to you before, they do not know how to respond. Or what kind of response you want. The other posibility, perhaps they have not checked that particular email account in a while. I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 16:08
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
I have one of those... The last time I checked it there was snow on the ground! Sad1
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 27 Apr 2008 16:09 (edited 27 Apr 2008 16:45)
Quote Report
ITA about the Thank you, Rory. Now matter how good or bad a fic is, and whether or not it is to someone's personal taste, if you put that much time and effort into something then the person should at least say Thank You. To answer your original question, I have written fics for a few people on this board (requests) and AFAIK they have always appreciated them. At least, that's what they tell me! ROFL 2
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 16:17
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
I have one of those... The last time I checked it there was snow on the ground! Sad1
That could have been last week, depending on where you live Animelol
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 16:20
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
I have one of those... The last time I checked it there was snow on the ground! Sad1
That could have been last week, depending on where you live Animelol
Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 16:24
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
I have one of those... The last time I checked it there was snow on the ground! Sad1
That could have been last week, depending on where you live Animelol
Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
Rory
Rory Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 16:37
Quote Report
REPLY TO EVERYONE: Clouddancer reminded me that I'm late for my interview. Waaaah! I'll be back tomorrow to reply to everyone AND post the infamous slash fic. Ja ne! (See ya!)
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 16:41
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer I know I have at least one account I forget to check regularly.
I have one of those... The last time I checked it there was snow on the ground! Sad1
That could have been last week, depending on where you live Animelol
Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
I cheat. When I know I'm likely to forget passwords or username, which has happened, I add it to a text file on the laptop. When I first got my email account in '99, it was a weekly event to click the little 'forgot password' link. So I got a clue! Programming
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 27 Apr 2008 16:46
Quote Report
Originally posted by Rory REPLY TO EVERYONE: Clouddancer reminded me that I'm late for my interview. Waaaah! I'll be back tomorrow to reply to everyone AND post the infamous slash fic. Ja ne! (See ya!)
Good luck!!!
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 16:47
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
I cheat. When I know I'm likely to forget passwords or username, which has happened, I add it to a text file on the laptop. When I first got my email account in '99, it was a weekly event to click the little 'forgot password' link. So I got a clue! Programming
I have learned to do that as well. Although I have it in a word document hidden in nested folders on my computer.
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 17:07 (edited 27 Apr 2008 17:08)
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
I cheat. When I know I'm likely to forget passwords or username, which has happened, I add it to a text file on the laptop. When I first got my email account in '99, it was a weekly event to click the little 'forgot password' link. So I got a clue! Programming
I have learned to do that as well. Although I have it in a word document hidden in nested folders on my computer.
Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 27 Apr 2008 17:10
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
If only Jun could do the same for her miniskirt.... Wink
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 17:13
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
I cheat. When I know I'm likely to forget passwords or username, which has happened, I add it to a text file on the laptop. When I first got my email account in '99, it was a weekly event to click the little 'forgot password' link. So I got a clue! Programming
I have learned to do that as well. Although I have it in a word document hidden in nested folders on my computer.
Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
Well .... I have bank account numbers in there as well. Something I learned from my father when he was an executer of a will. If you leave numbers and passwords around it makes things easier. You just do not want to make it obvious that they are there. IYKWIM.
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 17:18
Quote Report
Originally posted by Transmute Jun
Originally posted by Fairlight Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
If only Jun could do the same for her miniskirt.... Wink
I love the way your mind works, TJ!!!! whoo
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 17:19
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight Very true! Let's see...4 months. Yes, that makes me officially a bad email account owner!
And do you remember the password to get into that account now. When I depart from work/school for two months over the summer not checking my emails for that account I forget my login and password. Same applies to remembering the password to my work network system.
I cheat. When I know I'm likely to forget passwords or username, which has happened, I add it to a text file on the laptop. When I first got my email account in '99, it was a weekly event to click the little 'forgot password' link. So I got a clue! Programming
I have learned to do that as well. Although I have it in a word document hidden in nested folders on my computer.
Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
Well .... I have bank account numbers in there as well. Something I learned from my father when he was an executer of a will. If you leave numbers and passwords around it makes things easier. You just do not want to make it obvious that they are there. IYKWIM.
Very savvy, CD. Wink1
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 17:21
Quote Report
Hey, CD, pretty soon we'll have this whole page covered!!Lol
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 27 Apr 2008 17:37
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by Transmute Jun
Originally posted by Fairlight Smooth. No unwanted peeksies, eh?
If only Jun could do the same for her miniskirt.... Wink
I love the way your mind works, TJ!!!! whoo
That must be why I fit in so well on this site... Grin
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 17:58
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight Hey, CD, pretty soon we'll have this whole page covered!!Lol
LOL !!!!! That is what I was thinking too. That is why I removed some of the nested posts
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 27 Apr 2008 18:14
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer
Originally posted by Fairlight Hey, CD, pretty soon we'll have this whole page covered!!Lol
LOL !!!!! That is what I was thinking too. That is why I removed some of the nested posts
CD, are you trying to up your post count again?????
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 18:24
Quote Report
Well ... I had not thought of that really. I am already as high as I can go. The only posibility is to try and oust you out of first place but that is unlikely to happen. LOL unless I go back to doing lots of smilie posts in every thread. Wink3
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 18:25
Quote Report
Ohh Ohhh I know what it was .... I am trying to make the Owl a more prominate feature on this board Party4
Fairlight Boardie posted 27 Apr 2008 18:30
Quote Report
Originally posted by clouddancer Ohh Ohhh I know what it was .... I am trying to make the Owl a more prominate feature on this board Party4
It's like I tell my daughter, "What's the GP without an owl on board?" Same goes here!
clouddancer
clouddancer Gatchamaniac posted 27 Apr 2008 18:54
Quote Report
Originally posted by Fairlight
Originally posted by clouddancer Ohh Ohhh I know what it was .... I am trying to make the Owl a more prominate feature on this board Party4
It's like I tell my daughter, "What's the GP without an owl on board?" Same goes here!
I agree with you in part. The GP only needs the Owl onboard to fly her, otherwise it would be nice to be part of the action a little more often. Wink
Please login to post replies.