Problems with copyrights on Youtube

14 Replies 4277 Views 0 Likes 7 Participants Last post by yul 11 Nov 2007 23:12
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 10 Nov 2007 03:24 (edited 10 Nov 2007 04:20)
Quote Report
Hi, everyone, I just want to tell about problems with copyrights on Youtube. Not long ago I uploded opening video from one of Simpsons episodes where Marge was dressed as Swan Jun. Few hours ago I got Youtube notification that Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation claiming that this material is infringing and video was deleted. On the one hand they are right, but on the other hand I don`t think that Simpsons creaters had the same copyright to use Tatsunoko`s characters because it`s just a parody. IMHO, the fact of infringement looks like madness, in huge part of Youtube videos are used music, pictures and ect . which don`t belong to uploders. Of course, may be Twentieth Century Fox as well-known company prohibits using any of their materials, but there are a lot of other Simpsons stuff on Youtube. Something strange is happening. And it`s great that Tatsunoko and other companies which have Gatchaman copyrights don`t act like Twentieth Century Fox.
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 10 Nov 2007 03:49
Quote Report
Marge was dressed as Jun????? What have I been missing????? Doh2 ITA with you, Yul. It's annoying that they feel they have to 'protect' such short clips. But OTOH, I can see why they do it.
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 10 Nov 2007 04:14
Quote Report
It`s from 15S07 (FABF02) episode. Marge - Jun Lisa - Sailor Moon Bart - Astroboy ? Maggie - Pikachu Homer - Ultraman ?
amyltrer
amyltrer Gatchamaniac posted 10 Nov 2007 04:34
Quote Report
Hmm I've seen the ep too. On youtube as well. So I don't understand why did they deleted yours!
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 10 Nov 2007 05:32
Quote Report
Originally posted by amyltrer Hmm I've seen the ep too. On youtube as well. So I don't understand why did they deleted yours!
I think, may be unknown to Twentieth Century Fox icon of TV-channel in the upper right corner was the reason.
Springie
Springie Her Royal Fluffiness...Swan of Swans... posted 10 Nov 2007 06:31
Quote Report
Awwww, man...I'm sad I missed it! Well, it looks great, anyway!!
Hinotori
Hinotori Babbling Loonie posted 10 Nov 2007 06:39
Quote Report
Oh, wow, that's great! Too bad YouTube took it down, but thanks for posting the screen grabs!
Transmute Jun
Transmute Jun Queen of the Bird Missiles posted 10 Nov 2007 09:18
Quote Report
Those are great shots! Thanks for posting!
Sosai X
Sosai X Master Boardie posted 10 Nov 2007 14:35
Quote Report
While I'm not a lawyer, I believe that in the case of the simpsons, the use of tatsunoku's images are legal (at least in the US) because they would be deemed as fair use because they would be considered a parody. Course that doesn't stop some companies to try to shut down parodies/satire images that are legal. Sometimes they succeed and sometimes the courts don't let them succeed. I used to have a channel at Youtube and it got shut down because of too many copyright violations. I have no grudge about it - after all, I was using other people's property - but I was often surprised about what would bring the complaint. In my case it often was the more obscure stuff (mainly Space Ghost & Lupin III vids). Last year, Youtube was forced to remove something like 10,000 vids from the site that were Japanese music/movies/TV/anime clips because the Japanese companies objected to them. So it isn't just American companies that do it. That's my experience with Youtube. BTW, nice screen shots. Biglaugh2
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 11 Nov 2007 02:49 (edited 11 Nov 2007 02:51)
Quote Report
Originally posted by Sosai X While I'm not a lawyer, I believe that in the case of the simpsons, the use of tatsunoku's images are legal (at least in the US) because they would be deemed as fair use because they would be considered a parody. Course that doesn't stop some companies to try to shut down parodies/satire images that are legal. Sometimes they succeed and sometimes the courts don't let them succeed. I used to have a channel at Youtube and it got shut down because of too many copyright violations. I have no grudge about it - after all, I was using other people's property - but I was often surprised about what would bring the complaint. In my case it often was the more obscure stuff (mainly Space Ghost & Lupin III vids). Last year, Youtube was forced to remove something like 10,000 vids from the site that were Japanese music/movies/TV/anime clips because the Japanese companies objected to them. So it isn't just American companies that do it. That's my experience with Youtube. BTW, nice screen shots. Biglaugh2
Thank you for explanation, Sosai X. Corporation`s claims to Youtube is not difficult to understand, but at the same time there are a lot of other ways to share materials without any observance of copryrights such as sharing them in local Nets or for eMule. Youtube`s ploblem is that it is too popular among internet users. By the way, all episodes of Gatchaman I from ADV DVDs can be found here - http://www.torrentportal.com
amyltrer
amyltrer Gatchamaniac posted 11 Nov 2007 03:01
Quote Report
thanks Yul. I have downloaded some of the Gatch I eps, but I still haven't found absolutely nothing about the F series! If you see those on the torrents could you point them out to me, please?
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 11 Nov 2007 03:50 (edited 11 Nov 2007 03:51)
Quote Report
Originally posted by amyltrer thanks Yul. I have downloaded some of the Gatch I eps, but I still haven't found absolutely nothing about the F series! If you see those on the torrents could you point them out to me, please?
Unfortunately, I haven`t seen any episodes in Internet except first one from Gatchaman Fighters and 2 episodes from Gatchaman II. eMule Gatchaman II links I have found don`t work Sad
amyltrer
amyltrer Gatchamaniac posted 11 Nov 2007 04:52
Quote Report
Uhmm, I have the first three eps of Gatch F. I'm looking forwards to get more!
Ebonyswanne
Ebonyswanne Gatchamaniac posted 11 Nov 2007 19:15
Quote Report
That was cute! So the Eagle put on weight once he married Jun...could be from all the take out food since Jun can't cook!
yul
yul Exalted Member posted 11 Nov 2007 23:12
Quote Report
Originally posted by amyltrer Uhmm, I have the first three eps of Gatch F. I'm looking forwards to get more!
Where did you download them from, Amyltrer?
Please login to post replies.